The Problem with PowerPoint

by David Corr (4. January 2010 10:05)

When I was in college I had to take a public speaking class. In the class we were allowed to use 4” x 6” index cards to write notes on that would help us with our presentations. By capturing some key points on the index cards we were able to organize our thoughts, yet stay focused on the audience. Fast forward 20 years and the index card has been replaced with something much more intrusive and less effective – PowerPoint.

In the business world it seems that almost every opportunity where people meet you will see the dreaded PowerPoint deck. We have all had the experience of sitting through presentations were the presenter had far too many slides, slides that could not be read because they had detailed graphs and charts, or slides that were there just because the presenter thought they looked cool, yet added little value.  So we have to ask ourselves, since we have all experienced this,  why does it continue to happed? I believe that for the most part the problem lies with how people use PowerPoint. Rather than using PowerPoint as a tool to help a presenter connect with the audience and convey a message, many presenters use PowerPoint as a way to organize their thoughts and actually be the message. In this respect PowerPoint has become the modern day version of the 4” x6” index card; a queue card so to speak. It explains why some people just can’t hold a meeting without a PowerPoint deck, because without it, they wouldn’t know what to say. When presenters use PowerPoint as a queue card the presenter ends up focusing on the slides and not the message and the audience. When I look back on some of the most memorable presentations I have seen, I don’t think of how great the PowerPoint slides were; I think of the person, their personality, how they connected with the audience, the questions they asked, and the value of the information they presented. In fact, some of the best sales calls I have ever been on were those that did not use PowerPoint at all.

 Don’t get me wrong, when used correctly PowerPoint can be a very effective communication tool, and in many cases (webinars for example), a PowerPoint deck is a “must have.” But in today’s  world it is largely overused and often ineffective.

So what’s your take on PowerPoint as a communication tool?  Please share your comments.

Digg It!DZone It!FacebookLinkedInStumbleUponTechnoratiRedditDel.icio.usNewsVineFurlBlinkList

Tags: ,

Comments (5) -

3/11/2010 7:06:51 AM #

I think you made great points here David, many of which were driven relentlessly home to me and my classmates in the Mandel speakers training class that my boss required all of us to take.  I was ready to gripe, until the last paragraph, about the many remote presentations I give, and how I was supposed to interact with an audience that couldn't see me.  Even allowing for the need to have Power Point in presentations without a video link to the speaker, I can see that I need two versions of every presentation I give:  One that contains a few bullet points that I want the viewer to take away, in case they're looking at the slides without listening to my audio, and another one with almost no words to be delivered live.  I'm an abysmal presenter myself, but the good ones where I work (and there are many) NEVER look at their Power Point, and sometimes turn it off altogether.  Like you, I'm amazed that we seem to universally accept that Power Point is misused, but yet we perpetuate it on a corporate scale.  Where I work, Power Point presentations are expected everywhere, so a person would feel like they weren't doing what was expected if they didn't offer one.  Maybe I'll try one this year that has no words at all, just a series of appropriate background images that underscore what I'm saying.  Bet a lot of people will HATE that one.

Marvin Goodman United States

3/11/2010 7:32:46 AM #

I could not agree more! I have been working with my boss on his upcoming presentation. Slowly, he is starting to realize he has too much and too many slides. His presentation is 15 minutes - we still have 35 slides. Overkill.

Colleen Waters United States

3/12/2010 2:52:33 PM #

I wholeheartedly agree that PowerPoint is over-used and often misused. Real Leaders Don't Do Powerpoint is a great book that I recommend reading.

I recently did two presentations without PowerPoint and found that some audience members were bothered by there not being anything on the screen to look at. Perhaps audiences have become overly dependent on PowerPoint as well?

I plan on doing my next two presentations using PowerPoint for some headlines and visuals -- sort of a cross between a full-blown PowerPoint and none at all. I'm hoping this is the happy medium for me and my audiences.

Ari B. Adler United States

3/13/2010 8:16:20 PM #

I think it comes down to people's struggles to figure out what it is exactly they want to communicate to an audience... PowerPoint, by it's nature, can quickly overshadow the most important factor which is figuring out your message first and then determining how to get it across.  I consider myself very proficient with the tool and cognizant of it's limitations but STILL struggle with this.

A few things I try to do:
* Establish meeting objectives before writing slides
* Establish a meeting flow and meeting transitions using slide headers before putting any content into the slides
* Do the afforementioned things long before the meeting if possible so I can get away from the slides for a day or more and then come back fresh to finish them.
* Plan questions to the audience and points where I will try to turn the meeting back to the audience.
* Force myself to have someone else give me feedback when possible.

Rick United States

6/21/2010 9:25:10 AM #

People see Power Point presentations all the time. There is no novelty anymore. They can also be distracting, not to mention boring, which is why they aren't effective. I say we all go back to the old school index card method. The most engaging speakers can hold an audience's attention without a flashing screen, anyways.

Lisa Caponigri United States

Add comment




  Country flag
biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading


Recent Comments

Comment RSS

Blogs You Should Read

Berry Network employee blogs are published by Berry Network employees and reflect their own opinions, interests, trials, and tribulations. The entries don’t necessarily represent this company’s positions, strategies or views. But that doesn’t mean we don’t want you to read them! Because they do represent lots of marketing expertise you can’t get from anyone else.